I'm 14 years old and I play at a grade 9 RCM level.
Even when I started piano 5 years ago, others often told me that although I had the technique down, I was missing the emotion. I have slowly gotten better over the years but I still feel that I am lacking "feeling" in my musical performance. My piano teacher tells me to "sing" the piece while I'm playing it to add more movement, which I do.
Does anyone else have any other tips or is it just practice, practice, practice?
Answer:
Hello there... I'm glad you're looking for more expression in your playing. You ask such an important question, but it's also a very broad and heavy question because it encompasses nothing less than the individual style/voice that a pianist searches for and develops their whole life.
First of all, it's a common occurrence for a student to have mastered skillful technique in his/her performance but lack some "feeling" or "expressiveness." You're not alone. I have colleagues who play piano for a living that still suffer this problem.
"Feeling" in piano performance is a complicated thing; it's sort of undefinable. Some people have an intrinsic sense to expressiveness, where others struggle with it. It's the hidden x-factor in the greatest piano, and if you aspire to excellence in your playing, you will hopefully strive for this your whole life. Remember that as a pianist, you're a conduit to the past; you're sort of a door to the composer's brain and you're able to transmit the music to your audience as the composer heard it. But you're also an interpreter, and the choices and liberties you take in interpreting that music for us defines your voice and your style.
I wish I could give you one distinct answer that could solve all your problems, but it's not feasible and it's also a cheat, for it would take you out of that journey to your own voice. An excellent teacher can help you on this path, and I recommend finding the best teacher there is in your area. A good teacher will teach you the most important lesson: that a musician must understand not only the notes being played but why those notes were written in that order. You must understand the theory and analysis behind the music; in doing so, you can better understand how it makes you feel and why.
You can learn the technical tools for creating expressiveness: rubato, crescendo/decrescendo, ritard/accelerando, tone, feel, etc. You can spend your whole life adjusting the lightness of your playing, the release of notes and the phrasing. You can work on making leading tones sing so that you allow the audience to hear the melody. But all of this is secondary to understanding why the music should push or pull. I cannot stress this enough: study the music, learn the theory, and above all, let the music move you and use your instinct to decide how it should sound.
In the meantime, find the best teacher whose credentials are sound, and whose students play like you want to play. Listen to classical CDs of some of the most renowned pianists; better still, watch videos of their performances on Youtube. Take notes on how they begin and end phrases, what notes you hear most in a phrase, and how their articulation affects the overall sound.
I wish you all the best in your endeavors, and I invite you to email me if you have further questions.
Sincerely,
Peter Zachos
P.S. As a small example, let's look at a famous piece that I hope one day you will learn. Chopin's Fantasie Impromptu Op. 66. In the response section of the A theme (when the right hand plays triplet arpeggiated fifth-octave figures)... we've moved to the relative major and we hear, very simplified, a IV - V - I cadence played a few times. Every time the V harmony resolves to the I, the right hand melody, which previously is moving in this wonderful chromatic passing-tone motion, leaps to an escape tone; it leaps down to the natural 7 of the tonic, which as a leading tone resolves up to the tonic on the downbeat of the next measure.
If that last sentence was a bit rough for you to understand, it's okay. What's important is that every person you hear (or see on Youtube) playing the Chopin Fantasie Impromptu is going to interpret that wonderful escape-leap-to-resolution a bit differently; it's going to move them differently, and they're going to make a decision about how to play it. Should the tempo push a little to indicate more motion, a sort-of rush to move through the resolution? Should it give the barest hint of ritard, to set up tension for this resolution? Different pianists will hear it differently. Some will just play through it and do nothing. But the more you understand about what you're playing and how it's functioning musically, the more you will feel the music and its effect on your playing. Don't be daunted. It's a lifelong goal.